I am constantly amazed at the narrow vision of religion that is discussed amongst atheists and those who call themselves religious. Justin Trottier is the latest atheist to voice his opinion. There is more to religion than the belief in God. The West is rooted in ethical monotheism. Ethics is the most important component of Judaism and Christianity. The Golden rule is the prime example of the gift of religion to the world. Before ethical monotheism there was no concept of caring for the stranger which made it possible to move from tribal states to nation states. Before ethical monotheism there was no concept of free-will, the ability and the obligation to make choices, moral choices. And before ethical monotheism gods were capricious, there was no belief in a loving caring God to whom one could aspire to imitate.
 
Atheists believe that religion is a dead weight on science. I have a background in the sciences. I am well aware of the place of science in health-care. In my life, it was my connection to God and His teachings, his commandments, that kept me alive long enough for medicine to rescue me. Religion, for me and many others, provides an opportunity for greater wonder and awe in the world.

Science and religion are not incompatible. One needs only to read Jill Bolte Taylor’s “My Stroke of Insight” to know the connection. Ms. Taylor is a renowned neuro-anatomist. Charles Darwin wrote, “I cannot think of the world, as we see it,is the result of chance, and yet I cannot look at each separate thing as the result of design.” Einstein wrote. “The most beautiful experience we can have is the mysterious.” These people could see beyond the dogma and imagine the mysterious. Imagination is the prime mover behind scientific discoveries.

I often wonder why well-educated people turn to Manichean responses . I think it is fear. Fear of the unknown pushes us to black and white answers. Living with tension is difficult, yet, living with tension is to be fully human, truly alive.

This dismissive attitude toward religion by Justin Trottier exposes a lack of knowledge about religion.I don’t know how many times atheists need to be told that more people have been massacred in the name of secular leaders than in the name of religion.It is a refusal to accept facts as truth.

And yet, here he is at 29, the new guru, with his own pulpit, leader of a group of 1000 followers, teaching us about the horrors of religion. He, like so many others has no understanding of the gift of revelation. He is the recipient of these gifts. His free-speech, his judicial system, his concept of social justice comes from 3500 years of ethical evolution. He is so imbedded in it that unless someone tells him, he will never realize the gift religion has given to him.